Alex is Sprintlaw's co-founder and principal lawyer. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.
Many organisations begin with nothing more than an idea and a group of motivated people. Over time, the work grows, funding opportunities arise, volunteers join, or services expand - and suddenly the project needs a legal identity. This is when founders start asking whether they should form a not-for-profit company, register as a charity, or choose another structure that offers protection, credibility and long-term stability.
Although the term “not-for-profit” sounds like a legal category, UK law doesn’t treat it as a single structure. Instead, it refers to the organisation’s purpose: reinvesting surplus into the mission rather than distributing it for private gain. What matters is choosing the legal structure that best fits the organisation’s goals, funding needs and regulatory obligations.
What Is A Not-For-Profit Organisation In The UK?
A not-for-profit organisation is set up to pursue a social, community, educational, charitable, sporting, cultural, religious or other purpose, with surplus income reinvested into that purpose. It can still earn income, build reserves, employ staff and sign commercial contracts. The key point is that it isn't run to distribute profits for private gain.
For example, a youth arts organisation might earn £120,000 from grants, ticket sales and workshops. If its annual costs are £105,000, the £15,000 surplus can be used for new equipment, staff training, subsidised places or reserves. It shouldn't be paid out to founders simply because the organisation has done well.
Is A Not-For-Profit The Same As A Charity?
No. A charity is a type of not-for-profit, but not every not-for-profit is a charity.
To be a charity in England and Wales, your organisation must have exclusively charitable purposes and those purposes must be for the public benefit. Charitable purposes include relieving poverty, advancing education, advancing health, advancing religion, protecting the environment and promoting community participation in healthy recreation, provided the public benefit test is met.
If your organisation is charitable and its income reaches the registration threshold, it will usually need to apply to the Charity Commission. In England and Wales, an organisation must apply to register as a charity if its income is over £5,000 per year, or if it's a charitable incorporated organisation, because a CIO only exists once it's registered.
Charity status can improve public trust, open up charity-only grants and give access to charity tax reliefs. It also brings tighter rules. Charity trustees must act within charity law, manage conflicts, protect the charity's assets, have regard to relevant Charity Commission guidance where required and make sure funds are used only for charitable purposes.
Which Not-For-Profit Structure Should You Choose?
The structure affects your liability, governance, reporting duties, tax position, fundraising options and how easy it is to deal with funders, landlords, banks and employees. The main options are below.
Unincorporated Association
An unincorporated association is often used by small clubs, community groups and informal member organisations. It's usually quick to set up and can work well where the risks are low.
The drawback is that it has no separate legal personality. It can't hold property or enter contracts in its own name in the same way a company can. Committee members may end up signing contracts personally, which can create personal risk if the group takes on a lease, employs staff or owes money.
Company Limited By Guarantee
A company limited by guarantee, often called a CLG, is one of the most common structures for not-for-profit companies. It has members rather than shareholders. Those members guarantee a small amount, often £1, if the company is wound up.
A CLG can enter contracts, employ staff, hold assets and apply for funding in its own name. It's regulated by Companies House and must follow the Companies Act 2006. It doesn't automatically have charity status, but it can apply to become a charitable company if its purposes are exclusively charitable.
Charitable Company
A charitable company in England and Wales is a company limited by guarantee that's also registered as a charity. It's regulated by both Companies House and the Charity Commission.
Charitable Incorporated Organisation
A CIO is a legal structure designed specifically for charities. It's created by registering with the Charity Commission and doesn't need Companies House registration.
A CIO can suit a new charity that wants limited liability and a single charity regulator. It must have exclusively charitable purposes from the start, so it isn't right for a wider social enterprise that wants to operate outside charity rules.
Community Interest Company
A community interest company, or CIC, is a special type of limited company set up to benefit the community rather than private shareholders. A CIC needs a community interest statement, a constitution, an asset lock and approval from the CIC Regulator.
A CIC can be useful if you want to trade commercially while making a legally recognised community commitment. It can pay directors, raise income through trading and operate with business-like flexibility. However, it isn't a charity and doesn't receive charitable tax relief. If funders require charity status, a CIC may not be enough.
A business structure decision tool can help you think through the early options before you speak with a lawyer.
What Should Your Articles And Policies Include?
Your constitution is the legal backbone of the organisation. For a company, this will usually be its articles of association. For a CIO, it will be the CIO constitution. For an unincorporated association, it will be the association's rules or constitution.
A strong constitution or set of articles usually covers:
- Name And Legal Form: Identify the organisation and the structure being used.
- Objects Or Purposes: State what the organisation exists to do, with charitable wording if charity registration is intended.
- Not-For-Profit Clause: Confirm that surplus income must be applied to the organisation's purposes.
- Asset Lock Or Winding-Up Clause: Explain where remaining assets go if the organisation closes, usually to similar purposes rather than members.
- Membership Rules: Set out who can be a member, voting rights and when membership ends.
- Director Or Trustee Powers: Explain what the board can do and when member approval is needed.
- Payments And Benefits: State when directors, trustees or connected people can be paid or receive benefits.
- Conflicts Of Interest: Require conflicts to be declared and managed before decisions are made.
- Meetings And Decisions: Cover board meetings, member meetings, written resolutions, quorum and voting.
- Changes To The Constitution: Explain how amendments are made and whether regulator consent is needed.
You'll usually also need practical policies before taking money, volunteers or staff. These may include safeguarding, financial controls, expenses, complaints, conflicts of interest, health and safety, equality and diversity, anti-bribery, data protection and internal policies for staff and volunteers.
If you collect names, emails, donation details, health information, safeguarding records or service user information, UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018 apply. Your organisation should have a privacy policy, clear lawful bases for processing, secure storage, retention rules and processes for responding to data rights requests.
Can A Not-For-Profit Make A Profit, Pay People And Trade?
Yes. A not-for-profit can make a surplus, trade with the public, employ staff and pay suppliers. It can also pay directors in some structures, but the rules depend heavily on whether it's a charity, CIC or ordinary CLG.
For non-charitable CLGs and CICs, paying directors or founders is possible if the constitution allows it, the payment is properly approved, conflicts are managed and the arrangement is genuinely in the organisation's interests. For charities, trustee payments and benefits are much more restricted. A charity's governing document, charity law or Charity Commission authority must support the payment.
Employment law applies in the usual way if you hire staff. You'll need appropriate employment contracts, payroll processes, pension auto-enrolment where applicable, holiday and working time compliance, health and safety systems and fair disciplinary or grievance procedures aligned with ACAS guidance.
Volunteers are different from employees, but they still need structure and care. Clear role descriptions, safeguarding checks where appropriate, supervision, expenses rules and well-drafted volunteer agreements can reduce misunderstandings. Avoid language that accidentally makes a volunteer arrangement look like employment, such as guaranteed hours, wages or strong contractual obligations.
Trading needs particular care for charities. Charity trading profits are generally tax-exempt where they come from primary purpose trading, fall within the small trading exemption, or are channelled through a subsidiary trading company. If trading becomes significant, check the position with an accountant before relying on an exemption.
What Ongoing Legal Duties Apply?
Once your organisation is live, compliance becomes part of normal operations. Companies must keep statutory registers, maintain proper accounting records, file annual accounts and file a confirmation statement at least once every 12 months.
Companies House identity verification is now a practical issue for companies. Directors and people with significant control may need to verify their identity and provide Companies House personal codes, including when confirmation statements and other filings are made.
Charities have additional duties. Charity trustees must make sure the charity is carrying out its purposes for the public benefit, managing resources responsibly, complying with the governing document and reporting serious incidents when required. Reporting and audit thresholds can change, so check the Charity Commission rules for your financial year.
Fundraising also brings duties. If you fundraise from the public, the Fundraising Regulator's Code of Fundraising Practice sets standards for legal, open and respectful fundraising. You remain responsible for how fundraising is carried out, including where volunteers, platforms or third-party agencies are involved.
Some activities require sector-specific regulation. Care services may need Care Quality Commission registration, education settings may involve Ofsted requirements, youth organisations need strong safeguarding and DBS processes, and sports or health bodies may have their own rules.
Worked Example And Set-Up Checklist
Imagine a group called Green Streets Together. It runs community gardening sessions, pays freelance facilitators and wants to sign a three-year licence for a small storage unit. Its first-year budget is £48,000, with a modest surplus set aside for tools and reserves.
If the group stays as an unincorporated association, committee members may have to sign the storage licence and facilitator contracts personally. A company limited by guarantee would give the group a separate legal identity and limited liability, while keeping the not-for-profit model simple.
If Green Streets Together has exclusively charitable purposes, such as advancing environmental protection and education for the public benefit, it could consider a CIO or charitable company. If it wants more flexibility to run paid community gardening services and pay directors for operational work, a CIC might be better, especially if funders like the asset lock but don't require charity status.
A sensible decision checklist is:
- Are Your Purposes Exclusively Charitable And For Public Benefit? If yes, consider a CIO or charitable company. If no, consider a CLG or CIC.
- Do You Need To Sign Leases, Employ Staff Or Take On Significant Contracts? If yes, an incorporated structure is usually safer than an unincorporated association.
- Do Funders Require An Asset Lock? If yes, consider a CIC, charity or another structure with a suitable asset lock.
- Do You Want One Regulator Rather Than Two? If yes and you're charitable, a CIO may be simpler than a charitable company.
- Will You Pay Directors Or Founders? If yes, don't assume charity status will be straightforward. Document conflicts and payment powers carefully.
- Will You Trade With The Public? Map which trading supports your purpose and whether a subsidiary or accounting advice is needed.
- Will You Collect Donor, Volunteer, Member Or Beneficiary Data? Prepare privacy documents before collecting personal data.
- Have You Drafted The Core Clauses? Finalise objects, not-for-profit wording, member rules, conflicts, payment powers and winding-up clauses before registration.
Key Takeaways
- A not-for-profit is an operating model, not a single UK legal structure.
- A charity is a not-for-profit, but a not-for-profit isn't automatically a charity.
- Most growing organisations choose between a CLG, CIC, charitable company or CIO, depending on liability, funding, trading and governance needs.
- Your constitution or articles should lock in your purpose, surplus rules, member rights, conflicts process and winding-up arrangements.
- Companies House, Charity Commission, CIC, fundraising, employment and data protection duties can all apply, depending on how you operate.
- Choosing the right structure early can save you from difficult restructuring, funder delays and personal liability issues later.
If you'd like help with choosing a not-for-profit structure, drafting your articles or constitution, preparing governance documents or setting up volunteer and employment arrangements, you can reach us at 08081347754 or team@sprintlaw.co.uk for a free, no-obligations chat.







