Alex is Sprintlaw's co-founder and principal lawyer. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.
Usually, no: you shouldn't dismiss an employee for poor performance without warning unless the circumstances are genuinely exceptional. In England and Wales, capability is a potentially fair reason for dismissal, but you still need a fair process, clear evidence, a real chance to improve and the correct notice.
If someone isn't meeting the standard your business needs, it's tempting to move quickly, especially in a small team where one person's performance can affect customers, cash flow and morale. The safest route is usually not to ignore the issue, but to manage it early, document it properly and give the employee a fair opportunity to respond and improve.
That doesn't mean you have to accept poor performance indefinitely. It means you need to be able to show, if challenged, that you acted reasonably, followed your own procedures and treated the employee consistently.
- What Counts As Poor Performance At Work?
- How Is Poor Performance Different From Misconduct?
- Can You Dismiss An Employee For Poor Performance Without Warning?
- Can An Employee Be Sacked For Poor Performance During Probation?
What Fair Process Should Employers Follow Before Dismissal?
- 1. Identify The Specific Performance Gap
- 2. Hold An Informal Performance Conversation
- 3. Offer Reasonable Support
- 4. Put A Performance Improvement Plan In Place
- 5. Hold Formal Capability Meetings Where Needed
- 6. Use Warnings Before Dismissal
- 7. Hold A Final Decision Meeting And Offer An Appeal
- A Short Example
- What Should A Performance Improvement Plan Include?
- What Legal Risks Do Employers Face If They Skip Warnings?
- Key Takeaways
What Counts As Poor Performance At Work?
Poor performance, often called capability, is about whether an employee can do their job to the standard reasonably required. It isn't simply that you're frustrated with them, or that another employee performs better. You need to identify the gap between the role requirements and what the employee is actually doing.
Common examples include:
- Consistently missing realistic deadlines or service levels
- Failing to meet sales, output or productivity targets that have been clearly communicated
- Producing work with repeated errors or quality issues
- Struggling to use systems, tools or processes needed for the role
- Needing repeated supervision for tasks the role requires them to perform independently
- Not following agreed work processes because they don't understand or can't apply them
The key is specificity. Saying someone has a poor attitude or isn't a good fit will rarely be enough. Saying they have missed four weekly reporting deadlines, made repeated stock entry errors despite training, or converted 4% of qualified leads against a reasonable 12% target gives you a much clearer foundation.
You should also check the performance standard itself is fair. If targets are unrealistic, constantly changing or haven't been communicated, it becomes much harder to rely on them as a basis for warnings or dismissal.
How Is Poor Performance Different From Misconduct?
Poor performance is usually about capability: the employee isn't meeting the required standard because they lack skills, experience, understanding, training or ability.
Misconduct is about behaviour: the employee has done something wrong, such as dishonesty, harassment, serious insubordination or breaching workplace rules.
The difference matters because the process and outcome can be different. Poor performance normally calls for a capability or performance management process, including support, measurable targets and time to improve. Misconduct normally calls for a disciplinary process focused on investigating alleged wrongdoing.
There can be overlap. For example, an employee who repeatedly fails to complete safety checks because they don't understand the process may be a capability issue. An employee who understands the safety checks but deliberately ignores them may be a misconduct issue. Gross negligence or a serious one-off failure may sometimes be treated as misconduct, particularly in safety-critical roles, but you should be careful before labelling a performance problem as gross misconduct just to move more quickly.
Can You Dismiss An Employee For Poor Performance Without Warning?
In most cases, you shouldn't dismiss an employee for poor performance without prior warnings. Under the Employment Rights Act 1996, capability is a potentially fair reason for dismissal, but having a fair reason is only one part of the test. You also need to show that dismissal was reasonable in the circumstances.
At the time of writing, the usual qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal is two years' continuous service, but from 1 January 2027 this is due to reduce to six months for most employees. For employees who meet the relevant qualifying period, an unfair dismissal claim is a major risk if you dismiss without a fair process. A fair capability process will usually involve:
- Explaining the performance concerns clearly
- Giving the employee a chance to respond
- Considering whether training, support or adjustments are needed
- Setting measurable improvement targets
- Allowing a reasonable review period
- Issuing warnings where performance doesn't improve
- Holding a final meeting before dismissal and offering an appeal
The ACAS Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures is also important. While it isn't a statute that says exactly how many warnings you must give, employment tribunals take the Code into account. If an employer unreasonably fails to follow it, compensation can be increased by up to 25%. If an employee unreasonably fails to follow it, compensation can be reduced.
For employees who haven't reached the ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period, you may have more flexibility, but you still need to be careful. There's no qualifying period for discrimination claims, whistleblowing dismissals, certain health and safety dismissals, trade union-related dismissals or other automatically unfair reasons. You also need to comply with the employment contract, statutory notice and any applicable policies.
In practice, even where ordinary unfair dismissal protection hasn't yet applied, a short, fair process is often the safest business decision.
Can An Employee Be Sacked For Poor Performance During Probation?
Yes, an employee can be dismissed for poor performance during probation, but probation doesn't remove all legal obligations. It simply gives you a structured early period to assess whether the employee is suitable for the role, often with a shorter contractual notice period.
If a probationary employee is underperforming, you should still tell them what is going wrong, give them a chance to respond and consider whether extra support would reasonably help. A probation review meeting is often enough for a short-service employee, but you should keep notes and confirm the outcome in writing.
Before ending employment during probation, check:
- The employment contract and any probation clause
- The minimum notice required by the contract
- Statutory minimum notice, which applies after one month of employment
- Whether any issue could be connected to disability, pregnancy, family leave, whistleblowing, trade union activity or another protected reason
- Whether your managers have treated similar probation cases consistently
Statutory minimum notice is one week once the employee has been employed for one month, increasing by one week for each complete year of service up to a maximum of 12 weeks. If the contract gives a longer notice period, you usually need to follow the contract.
Poor performance isn't normally gross misconduct, so instant dismissal without notice is rarely appropriate. If you want the person to stop working immediately, you may need to pay in lieu of notice if the contract allows it, or otherwise handle the notice position carefully.
What Fair Process Should Employers Follow Before Dismissal?
A fair process doesn't need to be complicated, but it does need to be consistent. The more serious the possible outcome, the more careful your process should be.
1. Identify The Specific Performance Gap
Start with facts, not labels. Gather examples of missed deadlines, poor quality work, customer complaints, failed KPIs or errors. Compare those examples with the employee's role description, targets, training records and any policies they were expected to follow.
2. Hold An Informal Performance Conversation
For a first concern, an informal conversation is often the best place to start. Explain the issue, ask the employee for their view and listen for underlying causes. There may be workload issues, unclear instructions, lack of training, health concerns, bullying, personal difficulties or problems with tools and systems.
3. Offer Reasonable Support
Support might include refresher training, closer supervision, mentoring, clearer written instructions, workload changes, software access or regular check-ins. If a health condition or disability may be involved, consider whether reasonable adjustments are needed under the Equality Act 2010 before moving towards warnings or dismissal.
4. Put A Performance Improvement Plan In Place
If informal steps don't resolve the issue, a performance improvement plan, often called a PIP, can help. The PIP should be clear, measurable and realistic. Review periods often sit around 4 to 12 weeks, depending on the role, the seriousness of the problem and how long it would reasonably take to show improvement.
5. Hold Formal Capability Meetings Where Needed
If performance is still not improving, invite the employee to a formal meeting. Tell them the purpose of the meeting, provide the evidence you're relying on and explain that a warning or dismissal could be an outcome. Where a formal capability meeting could result in a formal warning, dismissal or other formal action, the employee or worker will usually have the statutory right to be accompanied if they make a reasonable request. Even where the strict right doesn't apply, allowing a companion can still be good practice.
6. Use Warnings Before Dismissal
A typical process may involve a first written warning, a final written warning and then dismissal if performance still doesn't improve. The number of warnings may vary depending on the seriousness of the problem and your policy, but jumping straight to dismissal for ordinary underperformance is high risk.
7. Hold A Final Decision Meeting And Offer An Appeal
Before dismissing, hold a final meeting and consider all the evidence, including any improvement, mitigation or alternative role options. If you decide to dismiss, confirm the reasons, notice position, final pay arrangements and appeal process in writing. Our guide on navigating termination of employment covers this in more detail.
A Short Example
Imagine you run a 12-person marketing agency in Manchester. You employ Sam as an account manager. Sam has worked for you for three years, so they meet the ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period both under the current position and under the expected rules from 1 January 2027. Sam keeps missing client reporting deadlines, clients complain about slow responses and reports contain budget errors.
Rather than dismissing immediately, you gather evidence, hold an informal meeting and discover Sam is struggling with new reporting software. You provide training and weekly check-ins. When the issue continues, you start an eight-week PIP with measurable targets for email response times, reporting deadlines and accuracy. You then hold formal capability meetings, issue a first written warning and a final written warning, and only move to dismissal after further missed deadlines, a final meeting, consideration of alternatives, payment of notice and an appeal offer.
That process doesn't guarantee there will be no claim. But it gives your business a much stronger position because you can show a clear standard, evidence of the problem, support, warnings, time to improve and a reasoned final decision.
What Should A Performance Improvement Plan Include?
A PIP is useful because it turns vague frustration into a clear plan. It also gives you a paper trail showing that the employee knew what was expected and had a genuine chance to improve.
A practical PIP can follow this outline. A lawyer should tailor it for your business, your role requirements and your employment documents.
- Employee And Role Details: Name the employee, job title, manager and start date of the plan.
- Performance Concerns: List the specific concerns with dates, examples and evidence where possible.
- Required Standard: Explain the standard expected, linking to the role description, KPIs, policies or reasonable instructions.
- Improvement Targets: Set measurable targets, such as accuracy rates, response times, sales activity, deadlines or quality benchmarks.
- Support Provided: Record training, mentoring, tools, supervision, adjustments or other support the business will provide.
- Review Period: State the start date, review dates and final review date.
- Possible Outcomes: State that improvement may end the PIP, partial improvement may extend it, and failure to improve may lead to warnings or dismissal.
- Employee Comments: Give the employee space to respond, raise concerns and confirm any support they believe they need.
You should avoid setting targets that are impossible to meet. If a PIP is unrealistic, a tribunal may see it as a box-ticking exercise rather than a genuine opportunity to improve.
It's also worth checking that your performance process is reflected in your staff handbook and contracts. For more on policies, see our article on workplace handbooks, and for a broader view of performance procedures, see our guide to a clear performance management process.
What Legal Risks Do Employers Face If They Skip Warnings?
The main risk, where the employee meets the relevant qualifying period, is ordinary unfair dismissal. A tribunal will look at whether capability was the real reason for dismissal and whether you acted reasonably in treating that reason as sufficient to dismiss. A weak process can make an otherwise understandable dismissal unfair, especially if you haven't given the employee a proper chance to improve.
Other risks can apply regardless of length of service:
- Discrimination: If performance is connected to disability, pregnancy, maternity, age, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation or another protected characteristic, you must take particular care. Reasonable adjustments may be required for disability.
- Wrongful Dismissal: This can arise if you fail to give the employee their contractual or statutory notice, unless there's a lawful basis for summary dismissal.
- Breach Of Contract: If your contract, handbook or policy promises a particular process and you don't follow it, the employee may argue you breached the contract.
- Automatic Unfair Dismissal: No ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period applies where dismissal is for certain protected reasons, such as whistleblowing, health and safety activities or asserting statutory rights.
- ACAS Uplift: Failing to follow the ACAS Code can increase compensation by up to 25% where the Code applies.
You should also think about practical business risks. Abrupt dismissals can unsettle the team, damage trust, create poor reviews and make it harder to defend your decision months later when memories have faded.
Before dismissing, check that you can point to specific evidence, the expected standard was clear, you've listened to the employee, you've considered support and equality issues, you've followed your documents, and you've dealt correctly with notice, final pay, holiday pay and appeal rights. If the answer to several of these is no, pausing to fix the process is usually better than rushing into a decision you later have to defend.
If you're unsure whether your current employment contracts or policies give you enough flexibility, you can arrange a review of your contracts or policies before the issue escalates.
Key Takeaways
- You usually shouldn't dismiss an employee for poor performance without warning, especially where they meet the ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period.
- At the time of writing, that qualifying period is usually two years, but it's due to reduce to six months for most employees from 1 January 2027.
- Poor performance is a capability issue, not the same as misconduct, and it normally requires support, targets, review periods and warnings.
- Probationary employees can be dismissed for poor performance, but you still need to check notice, discrimination risks and any contractual process.
- A clear PIP with measurable targets, realistic support and written review notes gives your business a much stronger paper trail.
- Skipping warnings can lead to unfair dismissal, discrimination, wrongful dismissal, breach of contract and ACAS uplift risks.
If you'd like help with managing poor performance, preparing a performance improvement plan, reviewing employment contracts or handling a fair dismissal process, you can reach us at 08081347754 or team@sprintlaw.co.uk for a free, no-obligations chat.
Get employment right
When should you get employment help?
Employment topics can become risky quickly when documentation, consultation, termination or contractor status is involved.








