Employee Share Schemes: A Guide (2025 Updated)

Creating a culture of employee loyalty and engagement in the era of side hustles can be a difficult feat. In 2025, with an ever-changing workforce, innovative strategies such as Employee Share Schemes (ESSs) are more critical than ever.

One way to do this is to give employees real ownership of the company through an Employee Share Scheme (ESS). This approach not only rewards hard work but also aligns employee interests with the long-term growth of your business.

ESSs directly issue shares to employees, while Employee Share Option Plans (ESOPs) enable staff to acquire shares at a predetermined price – typically vesting over time based on individual performance or company milestones. This dual approach helps establish a sense of ownership and commitment throughout your team.

These share schemes remain a popular method for motivating employees in 2025. For further insights on structuring effective incentive plans, you might find our guide on employment contracts particularly useful.

If you’re aiming to foster a deeper connection between your employees and the business, adopting an ESS could well be the best strategy for you.

How Can An ESS Be Taxed?

In 2025, employees are generally taxed on the market value of the shares or options they receive. These benefits are typically considered as income and subject to Income Tax. However, unlike wages processed through PAYE, employees are responsible for settling their own tax liabilities on these share-based benefits.

Significant tax advantages apply only to specific types of share schemes. The four primary tax-advantaged schemes are:

1. Share Incentive Plans
2. Save As You Earn (SAYE)
3. Company Share Option Plans
4. Enterprise Management Incentives (EMIs)

Key Factors To Consider

Employee Share Scheme

What Is It?

With an ESS, a company enables its employees to purchase its shares – often at a discount relative to fair market value. Shares may vest in tranches over a set period or upon achieving specific key performance indicators (KPIs), reflecting the company’s appreciation for each employee’s contribution.

Should an employee leave the company, rights to any unvested shares generally lapse automatically. Additionally, the company may have an option to repurchase vested shares at either current market value or a pre-agreed discounted rate. Some arrangements even include a put option, giving employees further security over their shareholding.

How Do Employees Engage?

ESS arrangements are typically straightforward since most people already understand what shares are, in contrast to more complex option-based plans. This simplicity boosts engagement and makes it easier for employees to see the direct relationship between their efforts and the company’s success. For best practices on drafting clear scheme rules, have a look at our contracts section.

What Rights Do Employees Get?

By issuing ordinary shares through an ESS, employees gain the same rights as any other shareholders. This setup means they are entitled to dividends and have the right to attend and vote at company meetings. Updated 2025 guidelines emphasise the importance of clearly defined vesting schedules and repurchase clauses to ensure that both the employer and employee are well protected.

Share Incentive Plans

Under Share Incentive Plans (SIPs), employees enjoy robust tax benefits. In 2025, well-structured SIPs mean employees do not pay Income Tax, National Insurance, or Capital Gains Tax on qualifying shares. This highly tax-efficient mechanism makes SIPs an increasingly attractive option for modern businesses. For more details on maximising tax benefits while remaining compliant, consider our legal health check for businesses.

Save As You Earn (SAYE)

The SAYE plan is specifically designed to help employees save over time. It allows them to purchase shares at a fixed price after a designated saving period. The main benefits are that interest accrued is tax-free, and there is no requirement to pay Income Tax or National Insurance while saving.

The main benefits here are:

• Tax-free interest
• No Income Tax or National Insurance charges during the savings phase

However, if the shares are sold later, Capital Gains Tax may be applicable based on current 2025 rates.

Company Share Option Plan

Much like the previous ESS arrangements, the Company Share Option Plan offers favourable tax treatment. Employees are not required to pay Income Tax or National Insurance at the time the options are granted, although Capital Gains Tax may apply when the shares are eventually sold. This plan is an excellent choice for companies keen to offer performance-based incentives.

Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI)

EMI schemes continue to be one of the most popular ESS options in 2025, particularly among start-ups and SMEs. Under an EMI, employees receive the option to purchase shares at a fixed price once they meet specific performance targets. As with the other schemes, there is no immediate payment required for Income Tax or National Insurance when the options are awarded.

The flexibility inherent in EMI schemes allows businesses to tailor the plan to their unique needs – adjusting vesting conditions and exit terms to best support company goals. For a deeper dive into optimising your incentive structure, our business structure guide offers valuable advice.

As the business environment continues to evolve, regularly reviewing and updating your ESS arrangements is crucial. Modern schemes in 2025 can be customised with flexible vesting schedules and exit conditions, ensuring they remain both competitive and compliant with the latest HMRC guidelines. Engaging with our specialists for a comprehensive legal health check for your business can provide you with the guidance needed to stay ahead of industry changes.

Talk to a Lawyer

ESSs can be incredibly valuable tools for both employees and employers. If you’re looking for a strategic way to retain your talent and enhance employee engagement, an ESS might be the right move for your business in 2025.

With ongoing changes to tax regulations and shareholder rights, it’s essential to consult with a specialist before rolling out any share scheme. Our experienced legal team is here to help you design a plan that not only meets your business needs but also complies with the latest legal standards. For further information on setting up your business for success, explore our startup legal guides.

Don’t hesitate to give us a call on 08081347754 or email us at [email protected] for a free, no-obligation chat about your share arrangement strategy.

---